
pub5. Image Formats for Preservation and Access: A Report of the Technology Assessment Advisory Committee
Lesk, Michael (Jul 1990, 10 pp.) ISBN: 1-887334-39-4.
Compares digital and microfilm imagery and concludes that making either kind of copy is preferable to leaving acidic paper to decay. Looks at image formats as they relate to preservation, storage, conversion, and transmission.
Barclay Ogden
October 1989
The national preservation program can save the contents of millions of brittle books through mass microfilming, but many library materials with scholarly value as artifacts also are in need of preservation. This paper provides an intellectual rationale for consideration of the book as an artifact and discusses possible selection strategies to provide a context for further exploration of these issues.
Some books and documents must be preserved in original form because they have scholarly value as objects as well as for the information they contain. The challenge of preserving these materials, called artifacts, requires an understanding of the scholarly value of artifacts and the development of an effective and efficient strategy for their preservation.
Research libraries and archives collect information recorded on paper, film, and, more recently, analog or digital tape and disks, all of which have finite life spans. When the original paper, film, and other information media or “formats” deteriorate sufficiently to threaten loss of the information recorded on them, a major preservation decision needs to be made: If the information is to be preserved, what is the most effective and economical preservation technology to use?
The decision can be difficult because no preservation technology is perfect; some information is lost in order to save other information, and decisions are made to save what is regarded at the time as information most likely to be of enduring scholarly value. Libraries and archives are filled with examples of compromises made to preserve some information at the expense of information considered to be of less importance. Microfilms and photocopies capture text but commonly lose much of the detail and tonal range of illustrations. Repairs and restorations alter original books and documents, no matter how carefully they are done. Even library bindings change forever the appearance of books as published by replacing original, sometimes illustrated, covers with serviceable, if unappealing, buckram.
For books and documents whose scholarly value lies entirely in a reasonably faithful representation of text and illustrations, the choice of an appropriate preservation technology can be made on the bases of technical fidelity of various reformatting technologies, the kind of access needed to the preserved information, and relative costs. For many materials of scholarly value at risk of loss from deterioration, microfilm is the preservation technology of choice because microfilm “captures” text well, and the text is of greatest scholarly value.
For materials valued for detailed, continuous-tone or multicolored illustrations, microfilm has not proven to be a good preservation technology. Moreover, materials made less useful by reformatting from paper to microfilm because the mode of access is less satisfactory are not considered good candidates for this preservation technology.
Even more challenging is the preservation of books and documents whose original formats have scholarly value as objects. These materials have scholarly value that encompasses both the value of the text and illustrations and, additionally, an object or artifact” value that is inseparable from the original format of the materials. They cannot be microfilmed without loss of part of their scholarly value. But exactly what are artifacts, what is their importance to scholarship, and how can artifacts be preserved effectively and economically?
Artifacts are often thought of in terms of rarity or uniqueness, age, and monetary worth. Although these characteristics frequently are found in artifacts, they do not of themselves determine scholarly value. Many books and documents are old and rare but contain little scholarly value, while some new documents may be of great importance. Similarly, the monetary value of some documents as collectors’ items has little relation to those documents’ importance to scholarship.
Most artifacts are valued primarily as evidence or proof of the accuracy of the information they contain. Original documents are essential for many legal and scholarly purposes as proof of authenticity. The authenticity of text, even its legal credibility, may depend on an analysis of the format. Erasure marks impressed upon the surface of a hand-drawn map warn that a location or boundary may have been falsified. Pages tipped into already bound books sometimes suggest that parts of texts may have been changed. Pasted-on changes to a typescript distinguish an author’s original words from those that found their way into print.
An original document is proof or evidence of how (and sometimes when and where) the document was made: the type of paper with its watermark printing or writing ink, the binding materials, glues, leather, and cloth. This evidence constitutes information about the history of the technologies involved in the manufacture of the document and often can help determine the date of an undated or inaccurately dated document.
Some artifacts are preserved because they are exceptionally fine examples of their technology or are artistic expressions. Some manuscripts, prints, drawings, and photographs made to record historical events were so finely done that they have acquired aesthetic value as well as value as historical documents. Some bookbindings are not only exquisite examples of their craft but also are artistic expressions wrought in leather, thus taking on the value of museum objects.
In all of the above examples, the format itself has something to contribute to the understanding of the book or document. Whether proof’ of authenticity, “evidence” of manufacture, or technological or artistic expression,” at least part of the scholarly value of the record is inseparable from its format. Can a copy, no matter how good, of a book or document offer the same proof of authenticity as the book or document in original form? (The admissibility in court of copies of original documents grapples with part of this question.) How can a facsimile provide evidence of the original manufacture of a book or document? Perhaps some forms of artistic expression would be less dependent upon original format if we had a preservation technology that could precisely duplicate the original and thus carry the same expression, but to date there is no preservation technology with this capability.
When the original form or format contributes to the scholarly value of the record, the record becomes an artifact. Consequently, the original format of an artifact cannot be destroyed without reducing the record’s scholarly value. From the perspective of making a preservation decision, should not we consider the original format to be “information” of scholarly value comparable to the words and illustrations more typically thought of as information?
By considering artifacts as information, artifacts could be subjected to the same scholarly and technical review given to all records considered for preservation. Books and documents valued exclusively for their contents currently are preserved only if that information is deemed to be of sufficient scholarly value to justify the cost of its preservation. Analogously, artifacts would be preserved only if their “information” is deemed of sufficient scholarly importance to merit preservation, knowing that preserving these materials means preserving them in original format.
Though not the primary consideration of this paper, in addition to artifacts there is a second category of books and documents that must be preserved in original format. These are library materials whose information cannot be captured by the currently available reformatting technologies of microfilming or photocopying. Art and art history, archaeology, architecture, geology, geography, the life sciences, and other subjects are heavily dependent upon illustrations that feature fine details, continuous tone, and color. Moreover, illustrated materials often are published in oversized formats with frequent foldouts. All of these characteristics make demands beyond the capabilities of filming and photocopying. Digitization is likely to overcome many of the limitations of current technologies, but it is not yet available for preservation applications. While they are not artifacts as described above, many illustrated materials also must be preserved in original form until a suitable reformatting technology is available for their preservation.
With many materials, and illustrated materials in particular, satisfactory preservation solutions are further limited by requirements for access. For example, comparisons among illustrations in art history texts require consultation of several images simultaneously, a difficult feat on a film or fiche reader. Reference books need random access for quick look-ups, which are not at all suited to the sequential access of the microfilm format. Thus the reformatting technology not only must capture all significant information, but also must provide quality of access equal to that of the original format if it is to be fully satisfactory.
If all books and documents of significant scholarly value are to be preserved, including artifacts and library materials for which a suitable preservation technology is not yet available, we must extend our efforts to preserve some records in original format. The information value of some formats in and of themselves, limitations of current preservation technologies to capture all significant information, and occasional special requirements for access indicate a need for a strategy for preservation of selected books and documents in original form.
Traditionally, libraries and archives independently have undertaken activities to preserve their collections by providing proper housing, protection from fire and theft, library binding, and occasional repair and restoration. Now libraries with custody of the nation’s research collections realize that a greater commitment of library resources is required to preserve their very large, deteriorating collections. The single, but monumental, problem of deterioration of library collections caused by embrittlement of paper alone has drawn considerable national attention along with additional Perhaps the least obvious (and most commonly overlooked) problem with the effectiveness of any preservation technology that reproduces or alters the original, no matter how “faithful” the reproduction or unobtrusive the alteration, is that the scholar is left with information less reliably accurate than that in the unaltered original format. Consequently, a preservation strategy for artifacts might include a guideline that no treatment should be undertaken unless the risk of damage from delay or inaction is judged to be the greater risk.
A preservation treatment must be appropriate and economical. Its appropriateness is measured by its ability to capture all information of significance. The scholar must be prepared to identify now what information is significant for current and future study in order to ensure that it is captured. Can a scholar always tell a conservator which attributes of an artifact are significant and must be preserved? The remote possibility of identifying all artifactual information that will in the future be significant about a book or document, combined with the inherent compromises between information saved and information lost during the preservation treatment process, appears to argue further for a preservation strategy to restrict extensive preservation treatment only to books and documents that have artifactual significance and that are in urgent need of treatment.
Some treatments used to preserve materials in their original formats are very expensive. “Full conservation,” or restoration, including chemical treatment and repair done to minimize its visual intrusiveness, can cost several hundred to more than a thousand dollars per book or document, depending on extensiveness of treatment. Relatively few artifacts can justify the costs of extensive preservation treatment but, fortunately, not all artifacts in need of preservation require extensive treatment. Most artifact treatments undertaken in many institutional preservation programs are minor, but are sufficient to enable the continued safe use of artifacts at a per item cost of less than fifty dollars.
The vast majority of all artifacts could be preserved without treatment and at low cost through preservation measures to reduce their rates of deterioration and wear, thereby extending their lives and minimizing the number of artifacts in need of treatment at any one time. Controlling the environment (temperature, relative humidity, air impurities, and light levels) reduces the rate of deterioration; protective enclosures mitigate the effects of a poor environment or housing arrangement and reduce wear; sensible handling and use practices help preserve artifacts for many decades of continued research. Soon chemical treatment, ‘mass deacidification,” will be available to reduce the rate of chemically caused deterioration. These measures could be the major components of a strategy for artifact preservation, with extensive treatment as a relatively minor component.
As with preservation of all library and archival materials, a strategy for preservation of books and documents in original format needs to encompass a justification for resources, methodologies for selection (assuming fewer resources than needs), and a range of preservation technologies able to match problems with solutions. Certainly artifacts could be claimed to have scholarly value sufficient to justify significant resources for their preservation. A preservation strategy could be crafted to meet the needs of both the most important artifacts and those most at risk. But the success of the effort will depend upon the involvement of scholars and librarians not only in identifying books and documents that must be preserved in original format, but in fully understanding the nature of the preservation problem to be solved and in developing a strategy for its solution.
Commission on Preservation and Access
1400 16th Street, NW, Suite 740
Washington, DC 20036-2217 (202) 939-3400
The Commission on Preservation and Access was established in 1986 to foster and support collaboration among libraries and allied organizations in order to ensure the preservation of the published and documentary record in all formats and to provide enhanced access to scholarly information.
The Commission on Preservation and Access
1785 Massachusetts Avenue, N.W.. Suite 313,
Washington, D.C. 20036-2117
(202) 483-7474
August 1989
The Commission on Preservation and Access was established in 1986 to foster and support collaboration among libraries and allied organizations in order to ensure the preservation of the published and documentary record in all formats and to provide enhanced access to scholarly information.
Librarians and scholars are vitally interested in developing strategies and establishing priorities for choosing which materials to preserve when not everything can be saved. This report is intended to stimulate further thinking on the part of the community of scholars who must have a voice in selection strategies.
There are more library books and journals in need of preservation today than can possibly be saved before they crumble and disappear. Accordingly, we cannot afford to spend resources on the preservation of materials that are unimportant. Choices must be made, and made with the best available advice as to the future scholarly value of the information to be saved.
The problem of brittle books arises from the acidic paper on which most books and journals were printed from 1860 to 1920, and the temperature and humidity conditions under which these volumes have been stored. About 30 million books in U.S. Libraries are, sooner or later, doomed to turn brown, brittle, and unusable. The problem is a national, not a local one, and only a concerted national effort has any hope of rescuing our cultural heritage. Libraries must cooperate in lending their salvageable volumes to the task and the federal government is the only possible source of sufficient funding. The result must therefore be a national collection, accessible to all scholars.
In this paper, “preservation” is used to mean saving the content of a brittle book whether through a gross transformation such as microfilming its pages, encoding its languages electronically, or reprinting it. Conserving” or ‘ restoring” the original item refers to attempts to save the physical artifact as well. The choice of mode may depend upon the rarity, uniqueness or special features (e.g., illustrations, typography) of the item, as well as upon the feasibility and cost of the technology employed. For the greatest part of the problem, microfilming appears currently to be the preferable mode of storage for preservation, although replication in other media from the storage microfilm may be preferable for use.
Manuscripts and archives also cry out for preservation or conservation, but present different problems than scholarly monographs and serials do. The latter are better known, defined, and classified than archives are, and constitute a somewhat more manageable problem because they are kept in well-ordered fashion in large collections that offer better accessibility for purposes of preservation. Printed works also serve a larger constituency than most archives do and their relative uniformity (compared to archival materials) makes them easier to process on a mass scale. Finally, the existing bibliographic network for printed works can be used advantageously in selecting items to be preserved and in minimizing duplication of effort among preservation projects. In view of the urgency of the preservation task printed works seem the best place to begin. Success in this area will pave the way for further support in others.
The needs and objectives of preservation vary widely across the several fields of scholarship. Literary and historical studies make much greater use of monographs, diaries and memoirs than the physical and biological sciences, where greater reliance is placed on journal articles and conference reports.
Correspondingly, in those areas of scholarship that focus on the movement and transformation of ideas; changes in the text of novels, plays, and poems; and connections among the cultural products of different eras and different places, there is often a demand for more extensive preservation–of each of the variant editions of a text, or each of several reproductions of a work of art. Such studies of stylistic or substantive variation are concerned with the changes or differences themselves in a work or a genre that is nominally the “same.” The need for multiple versions is not merely scholarly scrupulosity. Furthermore, in some subjects the preserved collection should knowingly include secondary, “inferior” or “popular” material, for scholars sometimes want to know everything that was being said about a subject even by tendentious or inaccurate writers.
Students of history (in any area) present a particular problem for a preservation strategy, for their scholarly mills can grind any kind of written or pictorial matter into historical grain. In principle, there is no topic, no place, no people, no event or sequence of events about which an historical account cannot be written. While the most trivial and frivolous topics are ruled out by the canons of scholarship, there is nonetheless a vast body of material whose preservation can be justified on the theory that someday someone will want to trace the historical changes in it or relate them to another body of material. Given such amplitude of potential resources, a strategy of selective sampling from some bodies of material–war veterans’ memoirs for example–is justified. Such caveats do not necessarily apply to the product of historical analysis, however, for the accomplished history of any topic, place, sequence of events, and so forth may be justified as a portion of the cultural record of the society in which it existed.
On the other hand, in the disciplines that accumulate knowledge by discovery of new data and revision of established principles, such as the physical and life sciences, the opposite is generally true. Working scientists are usually interested in the latest version of a book or the latest number of a journal. Great effort goes into updating, revising, and keeping current. Active investigators and teachers of science generally believe that most essential knowledge from the past is, for their purposes, adequately represented in text books, handbooks, and reference works. The earlier (and usually inaccurate or mistaken) theories, observations or inferences are discarded to the historian of science, not cherished for their current usefulness.
It appears, therefore, that the preservation problem is most pressing in the arts and humanities and, correspondingly for the reason cited, the choices of what to preserve or conserve are the most difficult.
Ideally, a selection strategy would invoke the most informed and prescient scholarly opinion about the future importance of each individual publication. there is neither labor enough nor time to make such a title-by-title approach feasible, however, even in a limited area, as a group of classicists, working collaboratively to preserve a mere 20,000 volumes, discovered. some less fine-grained strategy is necessary, and a couple suggest themselves.
One is a “great collections” approach that begins with an evaluation of the relative strength of collections by classification–e.g., the research libraries group conspectus. this inquiry produced a ranking of comprehensiveness of various libraries in specific subject areas–e.g., american history, philosophy, linguistics, medieval english literature. collections identified as “comprehensive” could be microfilmed in their entirety. indeed, it could be persuasively argued that since such collections had been identified, they should be the first to be filmed, in their entireties, for preservation. it is often more efficient to preserve all the material in a particular category than to deliberate lengthily about the relative importance of specific titles.
The wisdom of a “great collections” approach is usually apparent to scholars, once they have become familiar enough with the parameters of the preservation problem to appreciate the magnitude of effort required and the urgency of the task such consciousness-raising is essential furthermore, to the success of the preservation initiative, which cannot succeed without the understanding support of the academic community. a distinct effort of a particular sort needs to be made in this connection. scholars are ordinarily not familiar with the strength of library collections outside their own special fields, and indeed, may not be able to evaluate confidently the strength of collections outside their own university’s. further, many scholars have become accustomed to a title-by-title approach through a lifetime of judicious discrimination among individual authors, specific topics, stringently defined periods and other punctuate features of their intellectual arenas of work. they may initially resist what they perceive as a sweeping indiscriminateness of the “great collections” approach.
The scholarly community can be of great help in clarifying the requirements of research, advising on which materials are of little or no use, and which are essential for an academic discipline. scholars can help to make the judgment as to whether to preserve all of the items in a particular category or to choose a representative sample when there is great homogeneity of content among separate items–e.g., memoirs of war veterans, victorian moral philosophical tracts, self-help books.
Another approach, suitable for small segments of a scholarly field, is the use of an existing scholarly bibliography that presumably identifies the most significant work in, say, british empiricist philosophy or indic philology during a particular era when materials are known to be at greatest risk of embrittlement. alternatively, an individual scholar or group of scholarly specialists can draw up lists of authors whose work is considered important.
A variation of this approach involves enlisting the aid of the highly specialized sub-societies that can be found in most scholarly fields. for example, more than a dozen specialized interest groups in philosophy cover a range of topics: the leibniz society and the medieval and renaissance philosophical society, for example. members of such highly specialized groups can bring a particular perspective to bear upon a bibliography of the larger scholarly discipline and make judgments about its contents–or construct their own specialized lists.
In the latter approaches, whatever the source of the bibliography or the category of material, it constitutes simply the first step in selection, and must be followed by bibliographic cross-checking (e.g., through oclc or rlg records) to determine whether a preserved version of the item either exists or is planned. thirdly, a cooperative source, usually a university library, must be located to lend the item for the preservation process.
It is important to inform scholars about the need for preservation as well as the constraints– financial. logistic and temporal–that surround the process and equally important to involve them in making decisions about preservation. scholars’ understanding of the process that is developed for deciding what to preserve and its credibility are essential for overcoming resistance and for generating support. this need is particularly acute in view of the apparent necessity to choose a preservation process–microfilming–that has a bad name in the academic community generally. technically imperfect, carelessly executed microfilming has made even more unwelcome a medium that is greatly disdained in comparison to the familiarity and convenience of the bound book. a little direct experience handling the crumbling pages that can be found in any library, however, is a powerfully convincing argument in favor of preservation now–but the path toward that goal needs to be explored and discovered collaboratively on the part of librarians and scholars in order to reach it.
The urgency of preservation of the intellectual estate of the nation demands that the task be done expeditiously, while its vastness requires that it be done economically. Both of these dimensions urge that the strategies chosen be as simple and straightforward as possible, manageable by a wide variety of libraries, a broad spectrum of scholarship and a large assortment of materials. In an ideal world, unlimited resources and vast amounts of time would allow item-by-item selection on the part of scholars, exquisitely careful bibliographic checking by librarians, and restoration of the conserved (as well as preserved) work to the shelves of its lending institution. In the real world, all of these features must be compromised.
The issue of cost is crucial, given the vast quantity of deteriorating paper in libraries, and the cost of selection cannot be allowed to consume a disproportionate share of the total cost of preservation. As noted above, there are opportunities for economies in the logistics of preservation, and there clearly are economies of scale. Scholarly judgment is of the utmost importance in identifying important bodies of material, but it may be wiser as well as more economic not to attempt item-by-item selection but to sweep all of the items in a particular category/collection into the preservation process. Similarly, if the machine-searchable bibliographic networks of the country do not evidence the existence of a duplicate preserved item, that may be signal enough to include the item in the preservation process, even though we know that not all of the collections of all libraries are included in that database.
An important logistic issue concerns the willingness of libraries to collaborate by lending portions of their collection to a preservation process. The evidence of willing cooperation is, to date, immense. Yet there are signs that there may be resistance, especially on the part of faculty, to a collaboration that involves sacrifice of a volume or its non-return to the shelves of the university library. While librarians may be ready to recognize that, in order to retain scholarly content, it is reasonable to “destroy” a physical object before it self-destructs, faculty sometimes mourn or even rage. Such postures could have a distinct bearing upon selection for preservation.
The national program of preservation does not have a well-marked road ahead to travel, but the direction it must take is clear enough. Enough at-risk literature has been identified to justify an immediately increased effort to preserve it, and this effort will teach us much about the task. We do not know exactly what to do step-by-step, but we know what needs to be done: enlarge the involvement of scholars and librarians in the process, explain it to a generally sympathetic public and legislature, and learn as we go how to do the job better.
For more information on selection for preservation and the Commission Scholarly Advisory Committees, see Commission Newsletters No. 4, September 1988, page 2; No. 6, November 1988, page 1; No. 7, December 1988, page 3; No. 9, February 1989, page 2; No. 11, April 1989, page 2; No. 12, May 1989, page 4; No. 13, June 1989, page 1.
Scholarly Advisory Committees, composed of scholars and librarians, are charged with the Following tasks: to consider preservation selection criteria in light of the needs of the various academic disciplines; to advise on priorities and program directions within each discipline; and to act as liaison groups with the academic disciplines. Disciplines currently represented are history, art history, philosophy, and modern language and literature.