For Your Reference - S1:Ep 2 - The Aftermathematician

Content Warning: today's episode includes discussions about gun violence and school shootings.

How do we talk about violence? How we do we deal with violence after it happens? These are the kind of questions that drive Brad Serber’s work as a researcher in the rhetorics of violence and abnormality (Penn State University).

In this episode's Reviewer 2, Brad Serber (03:50) clues us in on a pattern in public discourse that has him worried: With every Sandy Hook or Uvalde another string of intense, partisan debate flares up (guns, mental health, location security, and law enforcement training), only to be stopped short and shunted back into the “rhetorical void” (08:28) by the next wave of breaking news. In the US, public conversations can’t develop naturally, cross-pollinate, or come to a resolution.

Without a working public forum—like the ancient Greek agora and law courts profiled in Serber’s forthcoming book Agora Phobia (11:00)—reactivity and fear start to perpetuate a logic of total prevention (“not one more!”), and it has serious consequences: “We’re actually setting ourselves up for failure...we say anything short of prevention is a failure, then it retraumatizes people every time another attack happens.”

The alternative? Serber says we should discard the rhetoric of prevention (13:05) for a rhetoric of preparation (13:38), which would bypass speculation about why these attacks happen (misogyny? mental illness? guns? xenophobia?) in favor of what now questions that would encourage readiness and response in the form of real-time knowledge sharing.

Reviewer 2 Discussion Topics Rhetorical Void (08:28) Rhetoric of Preparation (13:38) Stasis Theory (16:02) How to Research Targeted Violence (24:09)

In Check This Out (27:33), Paris and Joshua bring it home with some tips for media literacy practitioners researching targeted violence. Learn to build search terms from experience, analyze motive and context in your sources, and appreciate the full spectrum of multimodal information. This episode presents just the first half of the basic media literacy process.

Check This Out Discussion Topics Dunning–Kruger effect (29:49) Evaluating Resource Questions (38:27)

Get the rest in episode 3 (“Multifaceted Chicana”). Master the art to make an impact!

Brad’s Picks Fein, Robert A., Bryan Vossekuil, and Gwen A. Holden. “Threat Assessment: An Approach To Prevent Targeted Violence.” National Institute of Justice (U.S. Department of Justice) and Indiana University, 1995.

Follman, Mark. Trigger Points: Inside the Mission to Stop Mass Shootings in America. New York: Dey Street Books, 2022.

Klonick, Kate. “The Science of Blame: Why we respond to tragedies all wrong.” Vox. April 14, 2015.

McGraw, Seamus. From a Taller Tower: The Rise of the American Mass Shooter. Austin: University of Texas Press, 2021.

Rood, Craig. After Gun Violence: Deliberation and Memory in an Age of Political Gridlock. University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press, 2019.

Serber, Bradley A., and Rosa A. Eberly. “Rhetorical Dimensions of ‘Active Shooter’ Training Messages.” Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Communication. July 2017.